Coast Aviation Ltd was an interesting operator that flew between
Greymouth and South Westland in the 1950s and 1960s. It operated somewhat under
the radar and involved an interesting mix of personalities and operators,
including Buchanan Enterprises, Skyways Ltd, the Greymouth Aero Club and later
Phoenix Airways. These five entities were all interrelated in rather convoluted
ways.
The story begins with the first two strands that involve Malcolm Forysth and the Greymouth Aero Club. In a letter from the Greymouth Aero Club to the Royal New Zealand written on the 29th of October 1958 it is recorded that, Some three years ago (in 1955), Air Contracts Ltd of Masterton obtained a licence to operate a non-schedule passenger and freight service from Greymouth. Their pilot stationed here was Mr. Malcolm Forsyth. Air Contracts eventually were forced to sell this licence because of financial troubles of which you may so be aware. The purchaser of this licence was none other than Mr Blechynden. Needless to say, Mr Forsyth could not work far this man, and so set up his own flying school in Greymouth... The Aero Club here, would also have nothing to do with Mr. Blechynden, and as you are fully aware, made arrangements with Mr. Forsyth to carry out its flying training, a set-up about which we are still very happy.
So who was this Me Blechynden? Alex Blechynden, a pilot instructor from Hamilton, was the third strand to this complex operation. On the 16th of August 1956 he was issued with Air Service Licence No 170 which authorised him to offer air taxi and air charter services from Matamata and Greymouth to anywhere in New Zealand. He operated this licence under the name of Skyways. He owned three aircraft, de Havilland DH83 Fox Moth, ZK-ASP (c/n 4097), de Havilland DH82A Tiger Moth, ZK-AUQ (c/n132) and Ryan 511-2, ZK-BEM, (c/n 489) but only the Tiger Moth was used on the West Coast.
The fourth strand brings Henry Buchanan into the story. in his book, The Venison Hunters, Mike Bennett wrote, The credit for finding the first successful overseas amrket for New Zealand venison must go to Henry Buchanan, an ex-deer culler, then a crayfisherman of Jackson's Bay and Malcolm Forsythm a well known pilot of Greymoouth. The Haast in those days had no road access. Cattle were driven out along bush tracks through the mountains. All else came in and out by aircraft or ship. It was because of lack of access that Henry Buchanan acquired two aircraft, a Piper Apache and a De Havilland Fox Moth which he used to fly crayfish and whitebait out to Greymouth. Malcolm Forsyth had a Tiger Moth and was an experienced bush pilot.
Henry Buchanan had purchased de Havilland DH83C Fox Moth ZK-APT (c/n FM48) from
the Marlborough Aero Club, it being registered to him on the 27th of November
1956. The Fox Moth was used to support developing his business interests. On the 27th
of June 1957 it was sold to Malcolm Forsyth's Coast Aviation Ltd. Meanwhile, in June 1956 Malcolm had been appointed as pilot
instructor with the Greymouth Aero Club.
Coast Aviation's workhorse, de Havilland DH83 Fox Moth ZK-APT at Greymouth. Photo : I Coates Collection |
On the 22nd of May 1957 de Havilland DH82A Tiger Moth ZK-BNA (c/n DHNZ169)
had been registered to him. Three months later, on the 27th of August, it was
reregistered to Coast Aviation Ltd.
On the 5th of September 1957 the story further unfolded at an Air
Services Licensing Authority hearing in Greymouth. The Authority firstly considered
an application by the Greymouth Aero Club (Incorporated) for an Air Service Licence
to operate non-scheduled passenger and freight services from Greymouth and/or
Westport to anywhere in New Zealand. The Authority were also considering a
second application by Coast Aviation Limited for an Air Service Licence to
operate a scheduled passenger and freight service from Greymouth to Mussel Point
on Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday of each week and also a non-scheduled
passenger and freight charter services (including joy-riding) from Greymouth,
Westport, and Mussel Bay to anywhere in New Zealand. Coast Aviation Ltd was a
private company owned by Malcom Forsyth who had been the pilot-instructor to
the Greymouth Aero Club since June 1956, even though the Greymouth Aero Club.
The Christchurch Press recorded on
the hearing which seemed to weave the two applications together. Counsel for the
aero club told the authority that the club, which was reformed in 1955, had
a membership of 88, of whom 50 were pilot and student members.
The Civil Aviation Journal showed that 23 incorporated clubs in New Zealand had chartered licences similar to that sought by the Greymouth club. The vice-president of the club (Mr J. Dunne) stated that the application had first been made when the incorporation of the club had lapsed. The incorporation had been effected in June last. He outlined the number of flights undertaken by the club in the last nine months and added that an official of the Civil Aviation Department had suggested that the club should apply for a non-scheduled licence.
Mr M. D. Forsyth, pilot-instructor to the club since June, 1956 said his arrangement with the club was to train no-one other than a member and only pupil pilots were charged. Witness said his aircraft had been used under private licence and had carried potatoes for the Ministry of Works to Mussel Point. In further submissions, Mr Taylor said that, in view of the work at Haast Pass, there was a definite need for an air link between Greymouth and the other centres. The fishing Industry in South Westland also required a quick freight service from that area to Greymouth. If the application were granted, the company, Coast Aviation. Ltd., would not be taking business from any other concern, as there was no similar air service to the district.
Mr F. W. Spaakman, superintendent of mercantile marine, was called by the authority in connexion with the position of fisher men operating in the area. Mr J. B. Hood, president of the Hokitika Progress League, and Mr M, J. Sullivan, Fox Glacier, opposed the application on the grounds that West Coast Airways had taken over the licence from the National Airways Corporation at Hokitika last November, and they considered that two services were unnecessary. After a 10-hour sitting the authority reserved its decision.
The Civil Aviation Journal showed that 23 incorporated clubs in New Zealand had chartered licences similar to that sought by the Greymouth club. The vice-president of the club (Mr J. Dunne) stated that the application had first been made when the incorporation of the club had lapsed. The incorporation had been effected in June last. He outlined the number of flights undertaken by the club in the last nine months and added that an official of the Civil Aviation Department had suggested that the club should apply for a non-scheduled licence.
Mr M. D. Forsyth, pilot-instructor to the club since June, 1956 said his arrangement with the club was to train no-one other than a member and only pupil pilots were charged. Witness said his aircraft had been used under private licence and had carried potatoes for the Ministry of Works to Mussel Point. In further submissions, Mr Taylor said that, in view of the work at Haast Pass, there was a definite need for an air link between Greymouth and the other centres. The fishing Industry in South Westland also required a quick freight service from that area to Greymouth. If the application were granted, the company, Coast Aviation. Ltd., would not be taking business from any other concern, as there was no similar air service to the district.
Mr F. W. Spaakman, superintendent of mercantile marine, was called by the authority in connexion with the position of fisher men operating in the area. Mr J. B. Hood, president of the Hokitika Progress League, and Mr M, J. Sullivan, Fox Glacier, opposed the application on the grounds that West Coast Airways had taken over the licence from the National Airways Corporation at Hokitika last November, and they considered that two services were unnecessary. After a 10-hour sitting the authority reserved its decision.
It is clear that Alex Blechynden wasn't popular in aviation circles. The Press reported that on the
7th of October 1957 a deliberate attempt to prevent whitebait supplies
reaching Hokitika from Little River, in South Westland, which could quite
easily have caused loss of life. Mr Alex Blechynden, a pilot instructor
from Hamilton, is at present whitebaiting at Little River and uses a Tiger Moth
aircraft to fly out his catch to Hokitika. At 3 p.m. Mr Blechynden took off
from Little River, but after he had travelled only two miles, and was over
dense bush, the motor began to splutter. Mr Blechynden managed to turn the
aircraft around and was heading back to Little River when the motor cut out.
Fortunately he managed to bring the aircraft down on toitoi flats. Mr
Blechynden examined the petrol filters and found they were blocked with sugar.
After clearing the filters he took off again, landing at Paringa and Fox
Glacier, each time checking the filters. He flew from Fox Glacier to Hokitika
along the sea coast in case he had to land on the beach. At Hokitika, sugar had
again practically blocked the filters. Before he took off this morning for
Little River. Mr Blechynden said he had had a very lucky escape. “Had the motor
cut out before or after it did I would have crashed,” he said. Asked if he had
any idea how the sugar had entered the tank, Mr Blechynden said: “Well it just
doesn't get there by itself." Inquiries are being made by Greymouth
detectives led by Inspector G. S. Norris. Inspector Norris confirmed in
Greymouth this morning that a complaint “has been laid that foreign matter had
been placed in the petrol tank of the aircraft.” He would neither deny nor
confirm that the “matter" was sugar. This would be ascertained by an
analyst.
Later that month Piper Pa23-150 Apache ZK-BLP (c/n 23-1089) was purchased
by Henry Buchanan and registered to him on the 29th of October 1957.
An early photo of Henry Buchanan's Piper Apache, ZK-BLP, taken at Christchurch. Photo : D White Collection |
In November 1957 Alex Blechynden made an application to transfer his licence to Coast Aviation. The application had not been proceeded with when the applicant was advised that that there were objectors. Instead Coast Aviation made an arrangement with Alex Blechynden that allowed Coast Aviation to operate using Alex Blechynden/Skyways’ licence. Both Coast Aviation’s de Havilland Fox Moth, ZK-APT, and de Havilland Tiger Moth, ZK-BNA, were used as well as Henry Buchanan’s Piper Apache, ZK-BLP.
The Greymouth Aero Club letter to the Royal New Zealand of the 29th of October 1958 spells this oout a little more... Recently, you will remember, Mr Forysth, now operating as Coast Aviation Ltd. applied for a “charter” Licence but the application was declined, but at the same time this Club was granted a Joy-Riding Licence. Consequent on the application by Coast Aviation being declined, this Company had to find some other way of operating a non-schedule passenger and freight service, and in this connection an arrangement was made with Mr Blechhynden, to operate the Piper Apache under the licence held by “Skyways.” Prior to this arrangement, the Greymouth part of the licence had never been utilised. In a nutshell, all commercial flying apart from joy-riding, is carried out by Malcolm Forsyth in the Piper Apache and under the Licence held by “Skyways.”
On the 1st of September 1958 the matter was placed before the Air Services Licensing Authority when Mrs M. T. Blechynden sought the transfer to herself of a licence held by her husband.
Mr Gilbert pointed out that West Coast Airways took over the licence for the area from the National Airways Corporation when it was losing £6000 a year on its Coast operations. The new company realised that a substantial improvement would have to be made, but it was considered that the potential was available to make it economic to carry on. It was now claimed, however, that this potential had been lost through the illegal operations that had been carried on. Counsel then called evidence in support of his allegations.
In connexion with the irregularity of the operations, the authority pointed out that section 28 of the Act was the only section which gave it disciplinary powers of any sort, and its powers under the section were limited to licence holders. It was quite apparent, therefore, that the alleged irregular operations of Coast Aviation were no concern of the authority.
Coast Aviation's de Havilland Fox Moth at Hokitika on 3 February 1957 |
On the 10th of November 1958 the Fox Moth, ZK-APT, had a mishap when on landing at the Arawhata River it struck a tree stump. The undercarriage and main spar were damaged but the aircraft was able to be repair enough to allow it being flown out for more permanent repairs.
Mike Bennett continues the story of Coast Aviation's early flying in The Venison Hunters... There was certainly no shortage of deer. It wasn't uncommon to get a planeload of venison haunches for an evening shot — in fact there was more than enough meat for the plane to handle. The trouble was the West Coast weather. If it was fine in Greymouth it would be clapped out in the Haast, or vice versa. Distance was the weakest link in the chain of flying venison out of the mountains and up to Greymouth. The Fox Moth would land on rough, hastily improvised airstrips in the mountain valleys and ferry the meat out to the paddock airstrip on the sea-coast at Mussel Point, where the twin-engined Apache would be waiting. At the end of the day both aircraft, loaded to the roof, would head back to Greymouth. Weather permitting, the pilots, Malcolm Forsyth, Mery Dunn and Jeff Willeston, were kept flat out. Chillers were unheard of and we had only the crudest of meatsafes at first. But meat meant money for pilots and hunters; it had to come out...
Let us return to the cleaner air of early aviation in the mountains and the old Fox Moth for it cannot fly into the next chapter. Despite the many landings on unconventional airstrips, unknown to the then apparently sleeping Department of Civil Aviation, the ancient Fox Moth led a charmed life.
This collector's item of a biplane, with hopefully a motor behind the laminated wooden prop, would be thought flown by a maniac if seen today on a short bush-strip, let alone ready to take off with a load. Yet the only time it nearly came to grief on the meat was on one of the best of runways at the mouth of the Waita River. This strip had actually been formed by MOW's bulldozers, a method so often dreamed about by hunters toiling away with banjo and grubber. It was over 300 metres in length and had been built to provide access for surveyors pioneering the road north to Paringa in case the Haast was in flood. There were no helicopters on tap at that time.
A meat hunter had set up shop in a whitebaiter's but close to the strip, packhorsing his venison from way upstream. On this eventful day the Fox Moth trundled down the strip with about 200 kilos of venison haunches aboard, a good load at the best of times. The grass surface was sodden by days of rain and the pilot couldn't unstick the wheels — an important consideration if you wish to become airborne. The aircraft ploughed through a swampy section and vanished in a shower of spray, hit a bump at the end of the strip which bounced it sufficiently into the air to clear the first of the river channels. By amazing good fortune the wheels then hit a gravel bank in the middle of the river, which was running quite a bit higher than normal at the time; this bounced the plane over the second channel. Still struggling for flight, the Fox Moth hit the landward side of the sea-beach at one hell of a bat, and blew a tyre either through impact or by striking one of the many logs lying about. The horrified shooter watched it disappear over the top of the sand-dune, and dived into the river in hot pursuit.
The aircraft had slewed on the punctured wheel and was pointing back the way it had come. The tailplane was in the waves and the tide was making. The pilot was stunned and had a nasty cut on the forehead from hitting the instrument panel. He was helped out of the cockpit and soon came to, the hard-won meat was thrown into the tide, and both men tried to lift and push the plane back up the slope of dune. It wasn't on.
The pilot climbed back aboard and started the motor, the hunter then put his back under the wing, lifted and took one step forward, then had a breath for himself while the pilot brought up the other wheel by using the punctured one as a pivot. Halfway up the slope the hunter had had it so they changed places, and for the first time in his life the footslogger found himself at the controls of an aircraft, but it was certainly not going to take off with the first lesson as the pilot was unable to lift the weight. It was just as well that professional hunters have, as popularly supposed, weak heads and strong backs, for with an almost superhuman struggle the plane was eventually crabbed above high-water mark and tied to a log out of reach of the hungry sea.
By then, pilot and plane should have been on the way home to Greymouth. Darkness was not far off and the nearest telephone was fifteen kilometres away on the other side of the Haast River to the south. The Waita forded, the pilot's wound roughly dressed at the hut, and they started off for the Haast without even stopping for a life-restoring brew-up. They reached the Haast just on dark and alerted the ferry dingy by a hastily made fire. It was a close go, and possibly saved an embarrassing search-and-rescue flap the next morning.
A spare tyre unit for the Fox Moth was flown in the next day by Des Nolan in his Auster and the old aircraft which had been so close to a watery end was successfully flown off a beach of sand so soft that it was difficult to walk on.
Fox Moth ZK-APT on the beach at the Waita River. Source : Mike Bennett, The Venison Hunters |
On the 23rd of November 1959 the Tiger Moth, ZK-BNA, carrying a cargo of
venison, the property of West Coast Natural Food Supplies, was destroyed at Paringa.
The plane was about a quarter of the way down the runway when a sudden gust of
wind blew it off course into a belt of trees. Only part of the machine burst
into flames immediately, and this enabled the pilot, Don Smith of Greymouth, to
make his escape. The aircraft was totally destroyed.
Coast Aviation's ill-fated de Havilland DH82 Tiger Moth, ZK-BNA, at Greymouth in the late 1950s. Photo : I Coates Collection |
On the 26th of November the Press printed an article about West Coast Natural Food Supplies, which had established a major industry on the West Coast for the exporting of venison to America which was set up by Henry Buchanan and Malcolm Forsyth A company comprised of West Coast businessmen is exporting 10,000lb of venison a month, and it is gradually increasing that amount. This was disclosed yesterday by Mr Malcolm Forsyth, managing director of Coast Aviation, Ltd., one of whose planes was destroyed in a crash at Paringa on Monday last. The accident had caused a temporary setback to the firm, as it employed six regular deerstalkers, and the venison, which previously has been flown out from Paringa, will be brought to Greymouth by road in the meantime. The meat is treated at Greymouth for export to the United States and Europe. Mr Forsyth said the markets for venison could be expanded, but only if the production was also expanded. However, the company expected to be exporting about 80,000lb of venison each month. “It has been a great dollar earner,” said Mr Forsyth. “A consignment of 10,000lb is scheduled to leave New Zealand for Germany during the first week in December." That the continual shooting of the deer would go a long way towards keeping them under effective control, was the opinion expressed by Mr Forsyth. He said the animals were being shot ip areas inaccessible to vehicular traffic, but in close proximity to landing strips. Referring to the processing of venison, Mr Forsyth said it was thoroughly cleansed upon arrival in Greymouth, trimmed and wrapped in greaseproof paper. It was then placed in burlap bags, deep-frozen, and sent to Christchurch in refrigerated vans. It was exported from Lyttelton. The company had been in operation for only five months, and the product had proved very popular overseas, Mr Forsyth added.
A hangar at Greymouth Aerodrome was the first, crude processing plant to process the deer. In this later time Forsyth, along with Merv Dunn and Jeff Willeston, were the pilots. Bill Hende was one of the earlier pilots flying whitebait out of South Westland. The economics of flying the carcasses 200 kilometres eventually told financially and the company folded. Buchanan then established Buchanan Enterprises and relied on deer shot closer to the processing plant and to road transport.
Henry Buchanan's Piper Apache ZK-BLP back in Greymouth after being used by Northland Airways. Photo : D White Collection |
This left the Fox Moth ZK-APT as Coast Aviation’s only workhorse that continued
to fly whitebait and venison from South Westland to Greymouth. In the
June 2020 issue of Prop Talk, the North Shore Aero Club’s magazine, Ian Couper gives
a beautiful potted history of this work.
Another major use was to bring
the whitebait north for onwards transfer to the markets. The catch was never
predictable but none could be left behind. It is said APT once got airborne off
the beach over one thousand pounds overweight with the valuable whitebait, thus
carrying twice its own unladen weight. Climbing out of ground effect was not
possible, even as fuel was consumed, so it proceeded along beaches and over
coastal waters until Greymouth was reached, where the pilot put it down on the
beach to unload the precious cargo.
Life on the West Coast was hard for APT and in 1962 its Certificate of
Airworthiness lapsed. After its final flight to Omaka APT was condemned after a
CAA inspector was most disturbed at what he saw. “The general condition of the
aircraft can be described in one word – disgraceful. It would appear
maintenance has been of a negligible nature for some time. The cockpit has the
stench of an abattoir and it appears that the aircraft has been used for
carrying out deer carcasses on the West Coast.”
Happily, this was not the end for ZK-APT as it underwent a long term restoration by the legendary Stan Smith. Even though it was a later machine ZK-APT joins the Air Travel and NAC Fox Moths as one of the iconic aircraft of South Westland, one that continues to fly in our New Zealand skies.
De Havilland DH83 Fox Moth ZK-APT back on the Coast at Hokitika on 17 December 2009 |
No comments:
Post a Comment